This letter was sent to Congressman Bill Young, Senators Lemieux and Bill Nelson, and President Barack Obama:
This letter is intended to be read to all members of Congress and the Senate; please feel free to distribute it to all of your colleagues as you see fit.
You know, Washington, DC is an insane town. It is probably the only place on earth, at the only time in history, where enough power to heal the whole world or destroy it has been wielded by human beings. Imperfect, greedy, conniving, power-hungry, ambitious, talented, rich, spiritually all over the spectrum from depraved to decent, God-made, Satan-seduced political creatures who represent both the best and the worst of the very nation that represents, in turn, the best and the worst of mankind.
It is not without good, good reason that God saw to it there be a Constitution instituted to govern this people... this cantankerous, beautiful, powerful, morally decayed but still sometimes faithful tribe of Forgetters that first came to the fore after the twin sons of Joseph sired the most numerous, the most powerful, and the most troublesome parts of the great nation once governed by the wisdom of the two best kings that ever ruled, and fallen into disgrace because the second of those two kings lost his way at the end.
Now it has become apparent that like Solomon, ruler of a justly founded world empire ages ago, the custodians of today's even more justly founded superpower -- more justly founded because it derives its power from the consent of the governed by way of the written word of law, rather than through autocratic whim -- are about to sabotage the very contract by which this nation was founded to lose this nation's birthright for pottage in the manner of Esau.
I bear witness to you who read this that if this republic's leaders so derange themselves from its founding principles, embodied in its foundational written words, that states are played against one another for advantage and the legislative process is short-circuited with bills being declared passed without completed votes, then we will have destroyed the Union of these states as surely as Solomon destroyed the unity of the Kingdom of Israel and Judah at the end by his addiction to strange gods.
Be not addicted to foreign gods, God declared over 3,400 years ago. Do not be like the nations who desire a king over them and who worship idols. I tell you the truth -- if this Congress and this President chase the strange gods of socialism and populist autocracy, and abandon the Constitution that created the greatest nation on earth for the sake of health care or any other cause, you will destroy this nation and you will grieve over what you have destroyed for eternity.
Showing posts with label president. Show all posts
Showing posts with label president. Show all posts
Friday, March 19, 2010
Tuesday, July 7, 2009
The so-called "coup" in Honduras... ISN'T!
For over a week now the news media in the United States has been portraying the interim presidency of Roberto Micheletti, appointed by the Congress of Honduras to replace impeached and ousted President Manuel "Mel" Zelaya, as the leadership of a "coup." This is ever since the Honduran armed forces, acting on a warrant issued by the Supreme Court, and supported by Congress, arrested Mel Zelaya and sent him into exile on a Venezuelan airplane.
At this point you should be asking yourself, since when does a coup take place in the process of serving a warrant issued and authorized by a court of law, with the backing of the legislature? Have you ever heard of a coup d'etat that was authorized by a court order? And, why did Mel leave on a Venezuelan plane? Why not an American plane, or a Mexican plane, or a Salvadorean plane? I had to dig a little deeper to discover the truth about this, something the US news media is increasingly loathe to do when it conflicts with their leftist interests.
First I found this leftist writer, a member of the Washington Post group, named Alvaro Vargas Llosa, writing that Zelaya is to blame for this coup against him! Very interesting to see a leftist writer say that about this situation since Zelaya is a leftist himself, in fact, is a disciple of Hugo Chavez and tried to align Honduras completely within the orbit of Chavez's regime in Venezuela. Llosa writes,
"A member of the rancid oligarchy he now decries, Zelaya took office in 2006 as the leader of one of the two center-right parties that have dominated Honduran politics for decades. His general platform, his support for the Central American Free Trade Agreement with the United States and his alliances with business organizations gave no inkling of the fact that halfway into his term he would become a political cross-dresser.
"Suddenly, in 2007, he declared himself a socialist and began to establish close ties with Venezuela. In December of that year, he incorporated Honduras into Petrocaribe, a mechanism set up by Hugo Chávez for lavishing oil subsidies on Latin American and Caribbean countries in exchange for political subservience. Then his government joined the Bolivarian Alternative for Latin America and the Caribbean (ALBA), Venezuela's answer to the proposed Free Trade Area of the Americas, ostensibly a commercial alliance but in practice a political conspiracy that seeks to expand populist dictatorship to the rest of Latin America."
Up until this point, other than completely betraying his political party's platform, Zelaya had not broken any laws to my knowledge. That was also to change, as Llosa continues,
"Last year, following the script originally laid out by Chávez in Venezuela and adopted by Evo Morales in Bolivia and Rafael Correa in Ecuador, Zelaya announced that he would hold a referendum to set up a constituent assembly that would change the constitution that barred him from reelection. In the next few months, every legal body in Honduras -- the electoral tribunal, the Supreme Court, the attorney general, the human rights ombudsman -- declared the referendum unconstitutional. According to the Honduran constitution (articles 5, 373 and 374), presidential term limits cannot be changed under any circumstance; only Congress can modify the constitution; and political institutions are not subject to referendums. Honduras's Congress, Zelaya's own Liberal Party and a majority of Hondurans (in various polls) expressed their horror at the prospect of having Zelaya perpetuate himself and bring Honduras into the Chávez fold. In defiance of court orders, Zelaya persisted. Surrounded by a friendly mob, he broke into the military installations where the ballots were kept and ordered them distributed. The courts declared that Zelaya had placed himself outside the law, and Congress began an impeachment procedure." -- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/07/01/AR2009070103210.html?hpid=opinionsbox1
I'll let Oliver North pick up the thread here, after all it's only fair for these informational sources to be politically balanced. He writes,
"Late last year, as the Honduran economy tanked and unemployment grew to nearly 28 percent, Zelaya forced Elvin Santos, the country's elected vice president, to resign and began holding conversations with Chavez and Ortega on how to hold on to power. In lengthy Chavez-like populist speeches, he denounced the U.S. and wealthy landowners and linked himself with leftists in the Honduran labor movement. On March 23, he issued an executive decree directing a national referendum on a Venezuela-style constituent assembly to rewrite the country's constitution in time for presidential and legislative elections in November. The Obama-Clinton State Department was mute about all of this.
"Unfortunately for Zelaya's aspirations, the Honduran Constitution requires that amendments be passed by a two-thirds vote of the country's unicameral Congress during two consecutive sessions. By late May, the Honduran Congress, the Honduran Supreme Court, the commissioner for human rights, and the Honduran electoral tribunal all had overwhelmingly declared the referendum unconstitutional. Zelaya ignored the people's representatives, had ballots printed in Venezuela, and announced that the vote would take place June 28. Again, the O-Team was silent.
"In keeping with the rule of law, Honduran Attorney General Luis Alberto Rubi took the case to court. The Honduran Supreme Court ruled the referendum to be illegal and ordered the ballots to be confiscated. Late on June 23, Zelaya countermanded the court order and directed the army to distribute the ballots. Gen. Romeo Vasquez, the chief of staff of the Honduran military, sought legal opinions and decided not to distribute them. The following day, Zelaya accepted the resignation of the minister of defense, Edmundo Orellana, and fired Vasquez.
"The Honduran Supreme Court unanimously ruled the Vasquez firing illegal and reinstated him June 25. That prompted Zelaya and a group of supporters to seize the ballots and issue another executive decree, which directed government officials to set up 15,000 polling stations at schools and community buildings across the country. In response to a request from Attorney General Rubi, the Honduran Congress -- controlled by Zelaya's own Liberal Party -- opened an investigation into the president's mental stability and fitness to govern. Zelaya replied with a two-hour broadcast harangue, in which he claimed: 'Congress cannot investigate me, much less remove me or stage a technical coup against me, because I am honest. I'm a free president, and nobody scares me.'" -- http://townhall.com/columnists/OliverNorth/2009/07/04/wrong_again
Up to this point, you gotta ask yourself, what would the United States Congress... one that isn't bamboozled by a populist and numbed to sleep by infotainment about the death of a famous singer... have done about a man engaged in such naked grabs for power? I can tell you what they did to Presidents Andrew Johnson and Richard Nixon, and neither one of those Presidents ever went a tenth as far over the wall as Zelaya did in Honduras. You would think the ouster of such a tyrant in embryo, such a power hungry man doing his best imitation of an early Hitler or an early (fictional) Palpatine, would be welcomed by, at least, the Western world of constitutional democratic republics, limited monarchies, and the like. Even if some of those governments inclined toward liberalism, you would think that a constitutionally governed free nation like Honduras would be allowed to take care of its own internal wannabe Saddam Hussein without a chorus of objections from the entire world, after having seen recently what a Saddam Hussein did to the people in his own country.
Nothing could be further from the truth. One of the biggest culprits being the news media, in the worst hoax involving a Latin American government since the Hearst-led yellow journalism that started the Spanish-American War of 1898, headlines in every American newspaper have been blaring "COUP IN HONDURAS" with details in the articles emphasizing sympathetically how Zelaya was pulled out of his house in a gun battle and ushered onto a plane in his pajamas and told not to come back. Subsequent coverage has emphasized violent treatment of riotous protesters at the airport awaiting Zelaya's return. But not a whole lot gets reported about the very long, two year train of growing abuses of power that sickened every other branch of the Honduran government and most of the people to the point where the country's Supreme Court finally launched a legal proceeding to get rid of the scoundrel. I'm sure the military was all too happy to lead the assault, since Zelaya had also abused his authority trying to rearrange its hierarchy, too. But none of that seems to be reaching the halls of power in the rest of the world.
From the news I've been able to hear, the United Nations General Assembly, the European Union, the Organization of American States, and the United States have all condemned the impeachment and removal of Manuel Zelaya, and yes, they all call it a "coup" despite the non-factual, banal, and ridiculous application of the term. Honduras for its part has withdrawn from the OAS for the following reasons:
"'Insulza did not come here to negotiate; he came here to impose,' José Danilo Izaguirre, the Supreme Court spokesman stated.
"Honduras withdrew its membership from the OAS, after a visit by Insulza, the General Secretary, of the OAS, for proposing 'undignified and unilateral resolutions' in their case, demanding that Honduras give up its fight for independence by reinstating ex-President Manuel Zelaya.
"Honduran officials agreed it would be best to have 6 months of sanctions while elections are held, than to lose their independence." -- hondurasnews.com
So where does it go from here? At this point, the reactions in the West and in the United States government in particular have only degraded continuously as such luminaries as Secy. of State Hillary Clinton continue to shame themselves parroting the Chavista-OAS party line on Honduras:
"U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton stated taht the United States will support an international mediation effort to restore democratic order in Honduras.
"Hillary Clinton says she told President Jose Manuel Zelaya the U.S. supports a restoration of democratic order.
"Zelaya will participate in the talks, which Costa Rican President Oscar Arias will mediate.
"The provisional president of Honduras, Roberto Micheletti, also has signaled his willingness to participate, Clinton said.
"'We call upon all parties to refrain from acts of violence and to seek a peaceful, constitutional and lasting solution to serious divisions in Honduras through dialogue,' Clinton said. “We hope this process can begin as soon as possible."
I'm sorry Mrs. Clinton, but Honduras already HAD a constitutional solution to this "serious division" and it was the IMPEACHMENT AND REMOVAL OF MANUEL ZELAYA FROM POWER. NO other solution by any morally consistent, legal standard should apply!!
At this point you should be asking yourself, since when does a coup take place in the process of serving a warrant issued and authorized by a court of law, with the backing of the legislature? Have you ever heard of a coup d'etat that was authorized by a court order? And, why did Mel leave on a Venezuelan plane? Why not an American plane, or a Mexican plane, or a Salvadorean plane? I had to dig a little deeper to discover the truth about this, something the US news media is increasingly loathe to do when it conflicts with their leftist interests.
First I found this leftist writer, a member of the Washington Post group, named Alvaro Vargas Llosa, writing that Zelaya is to blame for this coup against him! Very interesting to see a leftist writer say that about this situation since Zelaya is a leftist himself, in fact, is a disciple of Hugo Chavez and tried to align Honduras completely within the orbit of Chavez's regime in Venezuela. Llosa writes,
"A member of the rancid oligarchy he now decries, Zelaya took office in 2006 as the leader of one of the two center-right parties that have dominated Honduran politics for decades. His general platform, his support for the Central American Free Trade Agreement with the United States and his alliances with business organizations gave no inkling of the fact that halfway into his term he would become a political cross-dresser.
"Suddenly, in 2007, he declared himself a socialist and began to establish close ties with Venezuela. In December of that year, he incorporated Honduras into Petrocaribe, a mechanism set up by Hugo Chávez for lavishing oil subsidies on Latin American and Caribbean countries in exchange for political subservience. Then his government joined the Bolivarian Alternative for Latin America and the Caribbean (ALBA), Venezuela's answer to the proposed Free Trade Area of the Americas, ostensibly a commercial alliance but in practice a political conspiracy that seeks to expand populist dictatorship to the rest of Latin America."
Up until this point, other than completely betraying his political party's platform, Zelaya had not broken any laws to my knowledge. That was also to change, as Llosa continues,
"Last year, following the script originally laid out by Chávez in Venezuela and adopted by Evo Morales in Bolivia and Rafael Correa in Ecuador, Zelaya announced that he would hold a referendum to set up a constituent assembly that would change the constitution that barred him from reelection. In the next few months, every legal body in Honduras -- the electoral tribunal, the Supreme Court, the attorney general, the human rights ombudsman -- declared the referendum unconstitutional. According to the Honduran constitution (articles 5, 373 and 374), presidential term limits cannot be changed under any circumstance; only Congress can modify the constitution; and political institutions are not subject to referendums. Honduras's Congress, Zelaya's own Liberal Party and a majority of Hondurans (in various polls) expressed their horror at the prospect of having Zelaya perpetuate himself and bring Honduras into the Chávez fold. In defiance of court orders, Zelaya persisted. Surrounded by a friendly mob, he broke into the military installations where the ballots were kept and ordered them distributed. The courts declared that Zelaya had placed himself outside the law, and Congress began an impeachment procedure." -- http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/07/01/AR2009070103210.html?hpid=opinionsbox1
I'll let Oliver North pick up the thread here, after all it's only fair for these informational sources to be politically balanced. He writes,
"Late last year, as the Honduran economy tanked and unemployment grew to nearly 28 percent, Zelaya forced Elvin Santos, the country's elected vice president, to resign and began holding conversations with Chavez and Ortega on how to hold on to power. In lengthy Chavez-like populist speeches, he denounced the U.S. and wealthy landowners and linked himself with leftists in the Honduran labor movement. On March 23, he issued an executive decree directing a national referendum on a Venezuela-style constituent assembly to rewrite the country's constitution in time for presidential and legislative elections in November. The Obama-Clinton State Department was mute about all of this.
"Unfortunately for Zelaya's aspirations, the Honduran Constitution requires that amendments be passed by a two-thirds vote of the country's unicameral Congress during two consecutive sessions. By late May, the Honduran Congress, the Honduran Supreme Court, the commissioner for human rights, and the Honduran electoral tribunal all had overwhelmingly declared the referendum unconstitutional. Zelaya ignored the people's representatives, had ballots printed in Venezuela, and announced that the vote would take place June 28. Again, the O-Team was silent.
"In keeping with the rule of law, Honduran Attorney General Luis Alberto Rubi took the case to court. The Honduran Supreme Court ruled the referendum to be illegal and ordered the ballots to be confiscated. Late on June 23, Zelaya countermanded the court order and directed the army to distribute the ballots. Gen. Romeo Vasquez, the chief of staff of the Honduran military, sought legal opinions and decided not to distribute them. The following day, Zelaya accepted the resignation of the minister of defense, Edmundo Orellana, and fired Vasquez.
"The Honduran Supreme Court unanimously ruled the Vasquez firing illegal and reinstated him June 25. That prompted Zelaya and a group of supporters to seize the ballots and issue another executive decree, which directed government officials to set up 15,000 polling stations at schools and community buildings across the country. In response to a request from Attorney General Rubi, the Honduran Congress -- controlled by Zelaya's own Liberal Party -- opened an investigation into the president's mental stability and fitness to govern. Zelaya replied with a two-hour broadcast harangue, in which he claimed: 'Congress cannot investigate me, much less remove me or stage a technical coup against me, because I am honest. I'm a free president, and nobody scares me.'" -- http://townhall.com/columnists/OliverNorth/2009/07/04/wrong_again
Up to this point, you gotta ask yourself, what would the United States Congress... one that isn't bamboozled by a populist and numbed to sleep by infotainment about the death of a famous singer... have done about a man engaged in such naked grabs for power? I can tell you what they did to Presidents Andrew Johnson and Richard Nixon, and neither one of those Presidents ever went a tenth as far over the wall as Zelaya did in Honduras. You would think the ouster of such a tyrant in embryo, such a power hungry man doing his best imitation of an early Hitler or an early (fictional) Palpatine, would be welcomed by, at least, the Western world of constitutional democratic republics, limited monarchies, and the like. Even if some of those governments inclined toward liberalism, you would think that a constitutionally governed free nation like Honduras would be allowed to take care of its own internal wannabe Saddam Hussein without a chorus of objections from the entire world, after having seen recently what a Saddam Hussein did to the people in his own country.
Nothing could be further from the truth. One of the biggest culprits being the news media, in the worst hoax involving a Latin American government since the Hearst-led yellow journalism that started the Spanish-American War of 1898, headlines in every American newspaper have been blaring "COUP IN HONDURAS" with details in the articles emphasizing sympathetically how Zelaya was pulled out of his house in a gun battle and ushered onto a plane in his pajamas and told not to come back. Subsequent coverage has emphasized violent treatment of riotous protesters at the airport awaiting Zelaya's return. But not a whole lot gets reported about the very long, two year train of growing abuses of power that sickened every other branch of the Honduran government and most of the people to the point where the country's Supreme Court finally launched a legal proceeding to get rid of the scoundrel. I'm sure the military was all too happy to lead the assault, since Zelaya had also abused his authority trying to rearrange its hierarchy, too. But none of that seems to be reaching the halls of power in the rest of the world.
From the news I've been able to hear, the United Nations General Assembly, the European Union, the Organization of American States, and the United States have all condemned the impeachment and removal of Manuel Zelaya, and yes, they all call it a "coup" despite the non-factual, banal, and ridiculous application of the term. Honduras for its part has withdrawn from the OAS for the following reasons:
"'Insulza did not come here to negotiate; he came here to impose,' José Danilo Izaguirre, the Supreme Court spokesman stated.
"Honduras withdrew its membership from the OAS, after a visit by Insulza, the General Secretary, of the OAS, for proposing 'undignified and unilateral resolutions' in their case, demanding that Honduras give up its fight for independence by reinstating ex-President Manuel Zelaya.
"Honduran officials agreed it would be best to have 6 months of sanctions while elections are held, than to lose their independence." -- hondurasnews.com
So where does it go from here? At this point, the reactions in the West and in the United States government in particular have only degraded continuously as such luminaries as Secy. of State Hillary Clinton continue to shame themselves parroting the Chavista-OAS party line on Honduras:
"U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton stated taht the United States will support an international mediation effort to restore democratic order in Honduras.
"Hillary Clinton says she told President Jose Manuel Zelaya the U.S. supports a restoration of democratic order.
"Zelaya will participate in the talks, which Costa Rican President Oscar Arias will mediate.
"The provisional president of Honduras, Roberto Micheletti, also has signaled his willingness to participate, Clinton said.
"'We call upon all parties to refrain from acts of violence and to seek a peaceful, constitutional and lasting solution to serious divisions in Honduras through dialogue,' Clinton said. “We hope this process can begin as soon as possible."
I'm sorry Mrs. Clinton, but Honduras already HAD a constitutional solution to this "serious division" and it was the IMPEACHMENT AND REMOVAL OF MANUEL ZELAYA FROM POWER. NO other solution by any morally consistent, legal standard should apply!!
Labels:
arias,
chavez,
clinton,
congress,
constitution,
coup,
due process,
eu,
Honduras,
impeach,
micheletti,
oas,
obama,
ouster,
president,
united nations,
zelaya
Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Proposing Constitutional Amendments.
It's become plain to me after all this time that America has too often been saddled with teams of duds in the executive branch. A President too often gets elected surrounded by yes-men and "handlers," and the Vice President has nothing to do except suck up, travel around and get photo ops (don't tell me he really does actual diplomacy or something, it's not even in his Constitutional job description.)
The Twelfth Amendment modified the procedure for electing Presidents in 1804 as follows:
"The electors shall meet in their respective states and vote by ballot for President and Vice-President, one of whom, at least, shall not be an inhabitant of the same state with themselves; they shall name in their ballots the person voted for as President, and in distinct ballots the person voted for as Vice-President, and they shall make distinct lists of all persons voted for as President, and of all persons voted for as Vice-President...."
See http://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/constitution.amendmentxii.html for the rest of it, but what that means is the President and Vice President since 1804 have been elected separately, each candidate campaigning for either one or the other office but not both. As a result the political parties developed what's called the dual ticket system, in which the slate put forth for the executive branch is two persons -- one for President, the other for Vice President, and the primary system these days (the caucus system before that) picks the Presidential candidate, and then they negotiate over who gets the Vice Presidential slot, with what I consider questionable results, especially recently.
After the Twelfth Amendment passed, I'm sure historians note that the quality of leadership in the country, with certain glorious exceptions, underwent a gradual decline since the first decade of the 19th century and has never really recovered. Admittedly it is hard to find national leaders of the stature of Washington and Jefferson in any era or nation, but we managed an era of excellence in leadership in the nascent decades of the United States. Not so much afterwards. So what was it we were doing right, before 1804? And why did it work so well then compared to later?
The Constitutional framers originally set up the system for electing the President and Vice President as follows:
"The electors shall meet in their respective states, and vote by ballot for two persons, of whom one at least shall not be an inhabitant of the same state with themselves... The person having the greatest number of votes shall be the President, if such number be a majority of the whole number of electors appointed... after the choice of the President, the person having the greatest number of votes of the electors shall be the Vice President...."
That means the electors chose two persons for the ballot for both offices together, the winner became the President, and the runner up became the Vice President. That meant that in George Washington's case, John Adams, the runner up in votes, became Vice President, and when John Adams was elected President, the runner up was Thomas Jefferson. In each case the two most capable men (as deemed by the Electoral College as a whole) were always selected for those two offices. If the runner up just happened to be in the loyal opposition, too bad, which is why the Democratic-Republicans changed it in 1804 with the Twelfth Amendment. But, can anyone argue that the presence of the opposition in the person of Thomas Jefferson kept John Adams on his toes when Adams signed bills like the Alien and Sedition Act into law? Contrast that situation with the next Vice President who happened to share the same party with his President, Jefferson, who entered the office already seasoned with experience in the executive branch. Burr was certainly popular once, but with the one-party system in full power, he was no Alexander Hamilton. The facts are that the Constitution was changed to a two-ticket system under a political party that had a supermajority in Congress and wanted nothing in its way, including potential trouble from Federalists if they ever got popular enough to win second place again, which they did within months of the Amendment becoming law.
What I believe this change destroyed was a potential and crucial role for the Vice President as an ombudsman and a critic of the Administration. Imagine the value of a Vice President Hubert Humphrey weighing in on some of Nixon's more controversial policies in Vietnam or regarding domestic surveillance or the principle of executive privilege. Would Kennedy have been assassinated if Nixon, Kennedy's best Republican friend, were waiting in the wings instead of his bitter internecine rival Johnson? Or how about Wendell Wilkie or Hoover in the 1930s, possibly keeping Roosevelt from veering far to the left and endangering the economic recovery in the Depression, or Jimmy Carter pulled centerward by Ford, or Reagan pulled centerward from the other direction by Carter? Can it be denied that George H.W. Bush would have better been served by a Vice President Dukakis than by Vice President Quayle? Or George W. Bush by Al Gore rather than Dick Cheney? Or Clinton by either Bush or Dole, rather than Al Gore?
I therefore think that, despite what one may believe about the policies and actions of any given President or election rival, that an oppositional Vice President not only guarantees the party out of power a voice in the Executive Branch, which is certainly deserved in a Republic where the minority retains rights against majority power, but it also keeps the government pulled centerward in an era when demagoguery and partisan politics often tempt leadership to steer the ship of state off a cliff just to prove its leftism, rightism, or whateverism to what it sees as its own constituency. A President needs to be reminded as often as possible that he or she is the President of the entire United States, and nothing could work better to remind a President of this than knowing that his or her chiefest opponent is sleeping in a large house one heartbeat down the block waiting for an opportune time.
The Twelfth Amendment modified the procedure for electing Presidents in 1804 as follows:
"The electors shall meet in their respective states and vote by ballot for President and Vice-President, one of whom, at least, shall not be an inhabitant of the same state with themselves; they shall name in their ballots the person voted for as President, and in distinct ballots the person voted for as Vice-President, and they shall make distinct lists of all persons voted for as President, and of all persons voted for as Vice-President...."
See http://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution/constitution.amendmentxii.html for the rest of it, but what that means is the President and Vice President since 1804 have been elected separately, each candidate campaigning for either one or the other office but not both. As a result the political parties developed what's called the dual ticket system, in which the slate put forth for the executive branch is two persons -- one for President, the other for Vice President, and the primary system these days (the caucus system before that) picks the Presidential candidate, and then they negotiate over who gets the Vice Presidential slot, with what I consider questionable results, especially recently.
After the Twelfth Amendment passed, I'm sure historians note that the quality of leadership in the country, with certain glorious exceptions, underwent a gradual decline since the first decade of the 19th century and has never really recovered. Admittedly it is hard to find national leaders of the stature of Washington and Jefferson in any era or nation, but we managed an era of excellence in leadership in the nascent decades of the United States. Not so much afterwards. So what was it we were doing right, before 1804? And why did it work so well then compared to later?
The Constitutional framers originally set up the system for electing the President and Vice President as follows:
"The electors shall meet in their respective states, and vote by ballot for two persons, of whom one at least shall not be an inhabitant of the same state with themselves... The person having the greatest number of votes shall be the President, if such number be a majority of the whole number of electors appointed... after the choice of the President, the person having the greatest number of votes of the electors shall be the Vice President...."
That means the electors chose two persons for the ballot for both offices together, the winner became the President, and the runner up became the Vice President. That meant that in George Washington's case, John Adams, the runner up in votes, became Vice President, and when John Adams was elected President, the runner up was Thomas Jefferson. In each case the two most capable men (as deemed by the Electoral College as a whole) were always selected for those two offices. If the runner up just happened to be in the loyal opposition, too bad, which is why the Democratic-Republicans changed it in 1804 with the Twelfth Amendment. But, can anyone argue that the presence of the opposition in the person of Thomas Jefferson kept John Adams on his toes when Adams signed bills like the Alien and Sedition Act into law? Contrast that situation with the next Vice President who happened to share the same party with his President, Jefferson, who entered the office already seasoned with experience in the executive branch. Burr was certainly popular once, but with the one-party system in full power, he was no Alexander Hamilton. The facts are that the Constitution was changed to a two-ticket system under a political party that had a supermajority in Congress and wanted nothing in its way, including potential trouble from Federalists if they ever got popular enough to win second place again, which they did within months of the Amendment becoming law.
What I believe this change destroyed was a potential and crucial role for the Vice President as an ombudsman and a critic of the Administration. Imagine the value of a Vice President Hubert Humphrey weighing in on some of Nixon's more controversial policies in Vietnam or regarding domestic surveillance or the principle of executive privilege. Would Kennedy have been assassinated if Nixon, Kennedy's best Republican friend, were waiting in the wings instead of his bitter internecine rival Johnson? Or how about Wendell Wilkie or Hoover in the 1930s, possibly keeping Roosevelt from veering far to the left and endangering the economic recovery in the Depression, or Jimmy Carter pulled centerward by Ford, or Reagan pulled centerward from the other direction by Carter? Can it be denied that George H.W. Bush would have better been served by a Vice President Dukakis than by Vice President Quayle? Or George W. Bush by Al Gore rather than Dick Cheney? Or Clinton by either Bush or Dole, rather than Al Gore?
I therefore think that, despite what one may believe about the policies and actions of any given President or election rival, that an oppositional Vice President not only guarantees the party out of power a voice in the Executive Branch, which is certainly deserved in a Republic where the minority retains rights against majority power, but it also keeps the government pulled centerward in an era when demagoguery and partisan politics often tempt leadership to steer the ship of state off a cliff just to prove its leftism, rightism, or whateverism to what it sees as its own constituency. A President needs to be reminded as often as possible that he or she is the President of the entire United States, and nothing could work better to remind a President of this than knowing that his or her chiefest opponent is sleeping in a large house one heartbeat down the block waiting for an opportune time.
Monday, October 22, 2007
My choices for President and Vice President
I once endorsed Ron Paul, a Republican Congressman from Texas, for President, and retired Gen. Wesley Clark, a former Democratic presidential candidate, as my choices for President and Vice President of the United States. I believed the two of them were the best choices because neither one seemed to be "owned" by any corporate interests, both were opposed to the war in Iraq, one is a veteran with loads of experience in defense matters, and both seemed to be quite interested in restoring Constitutional government and making it work for the people.
However, I found some problems with Paul's arch-conservative stances against abortion, against equal rights for people of alternative lifestyles, and for doctrinaire laissez-faire capitalism which I think has harmed the United States when it has been let run unchecked. Therefore I'm withdrawing my support of Ron Paul, and for now I am only endorsing Gen. Clark for President. I think I may write in Gen. Norman Schwarzkopf for Vice President pending a study of issues and causes he supports.
However, I found some problems with Paul's arch-conservative stances against abortion, against equal rights for people of alternative lifestyles, and for doctrinaire laissez-faire capitalism which I think has harmed the United States when it has been let run unchecked. Therefore I'm withdrawing my support of Ron Paul, and for now I am only endorsing Gen. Clark for President. I think I may write in Gen. Norman Schwarzkopf for Vice President pending a study of issues and causes he supports.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
